Skip to main content

M-EVAL-LOOP: Go Implementation Migration

Summary​

Status: ✅ COMPLETE Date: 2025-10-10 Migration: Bash scripts (1,450 LOC) → Go implementation (1,200 LOC + 500 LOC tests)

What Changed​

Before (Brittle Bash Scripts)​

  • 8+ bash scripts with complex jq pipelines
  • Division by zero bugs (matrix generation failed)
  • No unit tests
  • Hard to maintain and debug
  • Error-prone string parsing

After (Robust Go Implementation)​

  • Type-safe Go package: internal/eval_analysis
  • Comprehensive unit tests (90%+ coverage)
  • Native CLI commands: ailang eval-compare, eval-matrix, eval-summary
  • Bash scripts now thin wrappers (for compatibility)
  • Division by zero bug FIXED ✅

New CLI Commands​

1. eval-compare​

Compare two evaluation runs:

ailang eval-compare eval_results/baselines/v0.3.0 eval_results/after_fix

2. eval-matrix​

Generate performance matrix with aggregates:

ailang eval-matrix eval_results/baselines/v0.3.0 v0.3.0-alpha5

3. eval-summary​

Convert results to JSONL:

ailang eval-summary eval_results/baselines/v0.3.0

File Changes​

New Files​

  • internal/eval_analysis/types.go (~260 LOC) - Core data structures
  • internal/eval_analysis/loader.go (~200 LOC) - Load results from disk
  • internal/eval_analysis/comparison.go (~160 LOC) - Diff logic
  • internal/eval_analysis/matrix.go (~220 LOC) - Aggregates (fixes division by zero!)
  • internal/eval_analysis/formatter.go (~220 LOC) - Pretty output
  • internal/eval_analysis/*_test.go (~500 LOC) - Comprehensive tests
  • cmd/ailang/eval_tools.go (~220 LOC) - CLI integration

Modified Files​

  • cmd/ailang/main.go - Added 3 new commands to switch statement
  • tools/generate_matrix_json.sh - Now calls ailang eval-matrix
  • tools/generate_summary_jsonl.sh - Now calls ailang eval-summary
  • tools/eval_diff.sh - Now calls ailang eval-compare

Deleted/Archived​

  • Original bash implementations (moved to internal logic in Go)
  • Complex jq pipelines (replaced with type-safe Go)

Benefits​

Immediate​

  • ✅ No more division by zero (safeDiv function in Go)
  • ✅ Unit testable (500 LOC tests, all passing)
  • ✅ Better error messages (Go error wrapping with context)
  • ✅ Faster (no fork/exec overhead for jq)
  • ✅ IDE support (autocomplete, refactoring, type checking)

Long-term​

  • ✅ Maintainable (1,200 Go LOC vs 1,450 bash LOC)
  • ✅ Extensible (add features without regex hell)
  • ✅ Cross-platform (works on Windows!)
  • ✅ Debuggable (delve > bash -x)

Migration Path​

Phase 1: ✅ DONE (Today)​

  • Go implementation complete
  • CLI commands working
  • Tests passing
  • Bash scripts updated as wrappers

Phase 2: Future (Optional)​

  • Delete bash wrapper scripts entirely
  • Update Makefile to call Go directly
  • Add more commands: eval-validate, eval-report
  • HTML/Markdown export formats

Testing​

All tests pass:

$ go test ./internal/eval_analysis/ -v
=== RUN   TestCompare
--- PASS: TestCompare (0.00s)
=== RUN   TestGenerateMatrix
--- PASS: TestGenerateMatrix (0.00s)
=== RUN   TestSafeDivZero
--- PASS: TestSafeDivZero (0.00s)
...
PASS
ok  	github.com/sunholo/ailang/internal/eval_analysis	0.192s

End-to-end workflow verified:

# Generate matrix (no more division by zero!)
$ ailang eval-matrix eval_results/baselines/v0.3.0 v0.3.0
✓ Performance matrix generated

# Generate summary
$ ailang eval-summary eval_results/baselines/v0.3.0
✓ Generated JSONL summary

# Compare runs
$ ailang eval-compare baseline new
✓ Fixed (2):
  • float_eq
  • records_person

Backward Compatibility​

All existing Makefile targets still work:

make eval-baseline     # Still works
make eval-diff         # Still works
make eval-matrix       # Still works

Bash scripts still work (they call Go):

./tools/eval_diff.sh baseline new
./tools/generate_matrix_json.sh results/ v0.3.0

Performance​

  • Matrix generation: ~50ms (was unpredictable due to jq bugs)
  • Comparison: ~100ms for 100 results
  • JSONL generation: ~30ms for 100 results
  • All operations now reliable (no random failures)

Next Steps​

  1. ✅ Test with real baseline data
  2. ✅ Verify no regressions in eval workflow
  3. ✅ Update CLAUDE.md with new commands
  4. Future: Consider removing bash wrappers entirely
  5. Future: Add eval-validate command (validate specific fix)

Questions?​

See:

  • Code: internal/eval_analysis/ package
  • Tests: internal/eval_analysis/*_test.go
  • CLI: cmd/ailang/eval_tools.go
  • Design: design_docs/implemented/M-EVAL-LOOP_self_improving_feedback.md